The Tapestry

2026 Migration Literary Award

Vanitas: A Psychogeographic Story

Sharon VanStarkenburg

The word “matter” has its roots in the Latin “materia,” which originally meant “wood” or “the stuff from which something is made.” This, in turn, comes from the Latin word “mater” which means “mother.” Located in this etymology is the creative force of making, of turning raw material into a fresh form, of gestating ideas, of birthing new life. There is an ancient connection between our understanding of mothering and artmaking: of the psychic and physical connection to new life; of sacrifice and syphoning important resources to the project; matter, be it the stuff of body or mind, recombined. Subject matter, material exploration, but also maternity, materialism, and matriarch; these concepts live in a shared etymological constellation of substances, creation, and birth.

I have moved many times over the years, usually against my will, and it is particularly then that my collections of artistic objects and ephemera feel incredibly burdensome, when I must decide to box them or bin them. I have dragged the same photocopies to at least fifteen different homes and studios, each time agonizing over what to keep. I am compelled to display my collections, rather than store them away, so that my subconscious can work with my active mind, allowing for spontaneous connections and synchronicities, or surprising contrasts of materials, form, and ideas. I call this “atmospheric preparation,” which also includes reading, writing, dreaming, drawing, listening, and moving. I curate and switch up the visual fodder, often combing through my archives, anticipating a moment when an idea may crystallize. Vanitas is an exemplary piece of just such a process. I have been collecting vanity sets for several years, which I’ve used to decorate my powder room, adjacent to my home studio. I’d also had a vivid dream about a black flocked globe crowning a painting, so I’d purchased flocking tools and materials to experiment with and, in addition to the black, also selected a vivid, ultramarine blue. Thus, the raw materials for Vanitas were in my space, activated by the thematic concerns being worked out in my drawings and paintings.

Now, as I consider these assembled collections to write about them, I interrogate myself as to why I have an attraction to amassing decorative trinkets. The mirrors, for instance, like many things I collect, are objects I did not have as a child. They were superfluous, feminine, ornate, luxurious (even the cheap knockoffs), secular, and vain. Antiquated now, these sets tend to be mass produced baubles and, unless made of silver, are shoddy and have fallen out of fashion. What is their worth to me when they are no longer practical for use, stylistically desirable, or materially valuable? These types of objects were prohibitive to me on a number of counts as a child: I remember a fearful sense of financial precarity; on a religious basis there was a moral objection to both worldly excesses and vanity; and there was an especially strict, authoritarian approach to girls and women that sought to shrink both the female and feminine down to plainness, subservience, meekness, and humility. I grew up in a hermetic immigrant community in a small, rural town in Ontario. The center of this group was the Christian Reformed Church and all my socializing as a child (family, school, extracurricular) was deeply intertwined with it. My current desire can be understood as a corrective for the past: I can now indulge in luxury, vanity, femininity, frivolity, and excess as an act of both defiance and security.

•
Sharon VanStarkenburg, "Vanitas," mirror, silver stand, blue flocking, 2025, 10.5x7x5in

This is a story about how three distinct materials made their way to me and coalesced in the piece Vanitas: the mirror, decorative flocking, and ultramarine blue. It is an autoethnographic tracing of how they travelled East to West, meeting in the same city that would develop a religion and later ideology that would have a profound impact on my very DNA. Jane Bennett, in her book Vibrant Matter, challenges human-centric thinking, claiming all materiality is dynamic, changing, and an active participant. She names the active nature of the material world and its productive power “vibrant matter,” but also notes its negative correlative, or the recalcitrance of materials, in the ways that they can also be unruly. Bennett includes several histories and narratives to develop a pastiche of opinions and views to describe the agency of things. One such story is that of the mineralization of life on earth, thus breaking down the life-matter binary, endowing mineral and metallic life with vitality. She notes the human body is not necessarily one’s own, since it is populated and constituted by different swarms of “foreigners” and that we are, in fact, walking, talking minerals. The unfathomably slow migration of materials, including the minerality of our bones, the metal in our blood, and the electricity of our neurons, may prevent us from appreciating their volition. Yet, Bennett invites us to conceive of them as lively and self-organizing, rather than passive. Calcium, originally the dust of supernovas caught in a space cloud that eventually formed the Earth and other planets, has been cycling through rocks and oceans since. The human body can be understood as an aggregate of calcium and other raw materials, that since the Big Bang have been moving towards our personal iteration, slowly and with purpose. In this spirit, I imagine the long journey of the three materials brought together in Vanitas that eventually found me.

•

Nuremberg

In fact, I should say that our meeting in 2025 is a reunion of sorts, since our shared histories crossed in Nuremberg, Germany, around the year 1050. The first historical mention of Nuremberg, the nucleus of what would become a city, was of an imperial castle. “Nuremberg,” which combines two early Germanic words for “river” and “mountain,” began as a stronghold of landscape and architecture, sitting at the intersection of the East and West, via the Silk Road during the Middle Ages. As such, it became an important center for commercial enterprise, politics, and culture in the Holy Roman Empire. Kings and emperors sheltered in its protective, imposing landscape when they travelled, which made it a locale of international political transaction.

Naturally, the consolidated power of religion and politics, converging in the “treasure chest” of the Empire, drew economic prosperity. Nuremberg became a bustling marketplace, particularly known for textiles, printing, metals, and crafts. As a hub of scholarly pursuit, the city’s intellectual life was driven by the powerful merchant class that arose in the Middle Ages.

The Protestant Reformation, instigated by German priest and theologian Martin Luther, found purchase in the powerful stronghold of Nuremberg. The Silk Road brought to the city resources and technologies, and Luther capitalized on the unique combination of the coffee bean and the printing press, a duo that utterly transformed all aspects of life, especially in Europe. Nuremberg was one of the earliest adopters of the printing press and began publishing scientific, medical, religious, business, educational, and humanistic texts. The first major book printed in Europe was, of course, the Bible, which marked a vital shift in access to the text and possibilities for translation and interpretation. Luther used the printing press extensively to disseminate his ideas, particularly his 95 Theses, which he famously nailed to a Catholic church door in protest. Tracts and books were suddenly available to the masses, and many were tools for propaganda.

The surprising liquid that further fueled the machine of the Reformation was not ink, however, but coffee. Making its way through trade routes to Nuremberg like so many luxuries and innovations, coffee was one of the first stimulants experienced by Europeans. Coffeehouses became rich sites of printed matter, providing texts for study and debate. They were communal spaces that could reasonably store and protect such materials. For centuries alcohol had been the safest daily drink, leading to widespread habitual inebriation. Coffee provided a safe alternative that promoted alertness, an important force in the rapid shift of social and intellectual development. Nuremberg was one of the first cities to open coffeehouses, which became sites for intellectual debate for men. Women were routinely barred from such spaces, citing the coffeehouse as an unsuitable public arena. Coffeehouses became known as “penny universities” because they offered men a space of informal learning for the price of coffee.

Nuremberg was the first free Imperial City to implement the Reformation in 1525. Some of the core tenets of the new Protestant faith were: salvation is a gift that cannot be purchased; the Bible is the only source of divine knowledge, not the Pope nor councils; emphasis on individualism; and the constant need for forgiveness, not as a onetime act by a priest. The Church I was raised in is known as the Christian Reformed Church, a direct descendant of the movement Luther initiated. Together with the teachings of John Calvin, the Dutch Reformed Church began in the 16th century. The church was authoritative and rigid in its theology and social discipline, which emphasized God’s absolute sovereignty and gave power to its all-male church councils to discipline. The Christian Reformed Church was founded by Dutch immigrants during the “Afscheding” (Secession), who objected to the “overly liberal” elements within the original Dutch Reformed Church. My family, both on my mother’s and father’s side, is utterly defined by this belief system. Though my parents met in Canada and their families came from different parts of the country, there is a church in Rijnsburg, Netherlands that still stands that was built by my great, great grandfather on my father’s side and preached in by my great, great grandfather on my mother’s.

Thus, in 1050 a river and a mountain suggested themselves as the ideal site of shelter and a castle was built. From this protected geographical point, paths and roads were beaten into the soil by travellers bearing objects and technologies from afar. Under the confluence of religious and political power, wealth, intellectual and skill concentration, Nuremberg beckoned mirrors, flocking, and ultramarine blue while also inciting the Reformation. Each of these experienced its own reinvention, reassembly, and renewal: alchemical transformations that would “democratize” them so that these fine objects, once only available to the elite, could be enjoyed by the masses. Each took shelter there like kings and emperors, undergoing their own dormancy, awakening, and metamorphosis before continuing on their journey across the Atlantic.

•

Flocking

Believed to have begun about 3000 years ago in China, flocking was used to embellish objects with decorative and textured finishes. Nomadic tribes in Eurasia were among the first to adopt the technique of flocking, bringing the technology to the Middle East via the Silk Road. Initially, during the Middle Ages in Europe, flocked items were traded and sold as substitutes for velvet, but very quickly became luxurious objects themselves. The first evidence of mechanical flocking dates back to a 12th century Nuremberg monastery. Nuremberg monasteries perfected the flocking technique, which was kept secret, as were many trade innovations developed not only in monasteries and guilds, but many sites of male communion. Significantly, restricted access for women was a common trait in these sites of learning, leisure and expertise.

The Reformation devastated many crafts, including flocking, due to the shuttering of monasteries and a theological shift away from Catholic communal and institutional practices. Protestantism brought with it distrust of the ornamental, moral judgements regarding idolatry, and individualized participation in both personal and public life. Nuremburg city council seized monastic properties and assets to repurpose them, which meant that the secret methods of flocking were misplaced for some time. Flocking became dormant for about 200 years, sleeping in back rooms and on the surfaces of objects collecting dust, until the Renaissance lust for luxury revived the technique. Along with an obsession for Classical antiquity, human achievement, sophisticated arts and craftsmanship, and a burgeoning middle class, flocking as a status and luxury item was revived. It thus resumed its journey from Nuremberg, as a rediscovered object, further West until it reached the ocean shores and boarded a ship to North America as a material of wealth and taste by colonizers.

Later, during the Industrial Revolution, the evolution of flocking technology brought down its relative cost, though its association with the look of luxury remains to this day. In the 20th century, the electrostatic application of flocking fibres was perfected so that it was no longer a painstaking process by hand. Suddenly capable to mass produce, flocking became accessible, first in wallpaper, then in fashion, decor and automotive interiors. Eventually it became common, used in everyday products including cosmetic cases, phonographs, photocopiers, fax machines, speakers, paint rollers, and more; it has become almost tasteless in its ubiquity. This is how I met flocking as a child, I was oblivious to its tackiness, only seeing it as finery and the finish of objects I so desired: the interior of jewellery or music boxes, feminine accessories, and ornamentation. Flocking to me now suggests interiority, the texture of shaved legs, and the delicate bed of prized possessions. It speaks of the feminine detail, still derided as excess, now dismissed as cheap and unbecoming in its everywhereness.

•

Mirrors

Mirrors were invented around 6000 BCE in what is now Turkey, made from polished obsidian, and later polished copper and bronze mirrors were developed in Mesopotamia and Egypt. Initially, mirrors were primarily ceremonial or spiritual objects, often to ward off evil spirits, to communicate with ancestors, or to scry. Queen Elizabeth I’s court astrologer/alchemist/antiquarian, John Dee, used one of his scrying glasses to communicate with angels and unlock profound knowledge. In 1373 (three hundred years before the Queen’s birth) the first recorded guild of mirror makers opened in Nuremberg, making it the epicenter of European mirror production for centuries. The city’s medieval guilds and trades tradition fostered metalworking and glassmaking, the convex mirror was perfected in the 15th century. The “Nuremberg mirror” (also called the witch’s eye) was the standard until the process for creating modern glass mirrors was devised in Venice. Mirrors were an extremely expensive luxury item made with expensive, fragile, volatile, and deadly materials.

During the Reformation, the perception and use of mirrors was impacted by theological concerns about vanity and idolatry, linking excessive attention to physical appearances with the sin of pride. It was in the Dutch Golden Age that iconoclastic and Puritanical proponents located moral impurity especially in mirrors. Displaying material wealth was considered a social and moral concern, and especially in Dutch culture, communal monitoring of behaviour was meant to ensure compliance. Vanitas paintings were justifiable luxuries because of their purported pedagogical use in teaching reverence. The technology for glass mirrors gained momentum elsewhere while their consumption experienced a downturn amongst the Protestant public, as they signaled ostentatiousness and vanity.

Mirror technology in Nuremberg languished for some time, allowing Venice and France to flourish, while it awaited the chemical reaction that would bring it back to life. In 1835 German chemist, Justus von Liebig, invented the modern silvered-glass mirror. Liebig’s father owned a drysalter and hardware shop not far from Nuremberg in which he compounded and sold paints, varnishes and pigments. Justus, fascinated by his father’s alchemical interests, performed his own chemistry experiments in his father’s laboratory. At the age of 13 he lived through “the year without a summer,” when the majority of crops were destroyed in Northern Europe due to a volcanic winter. Because of his experience with this famine, he dedicated much of his life to the chemistry of agriculture. He is considered one of the principal founders of organic chemistry and established the standard for safety in laboratories. In fact, Liebig invented the modern mirror because before silvering, mercury mirrors caused sickness and death due to toxic exposure. He was determined to make mirrors safer, more durable and clearer. Doing so led to them being manufactured on an industrial scale, making domestic mirrors affordable for the first time. Thus, the proliferation of handheld mirrors began in earnest, prompting them to board North America-bound ships in great numbers as trinkets for the middle to upper class. They entered the boudoirs of ladies and laid atop the glass counters of department stores. Such looking glasses became common for personal grooming. Self-presentation came to viewed as an important individual project, especially for women. It was under these circumstances that personal mirrors, in the form of handheld or compact case, came into my consciousness.

Such mirrors were luxurious items I’d glimpse, perhaps, on the vanity table of a friend’s mother, inside a plastic purse of one of my playmates or as part of a Barbie set. Of course we had mirrors in our house, but their use was for assurances of cleanliness and modesty. Proverbs 31:30 says, “charm is deceitful, and beauty is vain, but a woman who fears the Lord is to be praised” and 1 Timothy 2: 9-10, “likewise, the women should dress modestly, with decency and propriety, adorning themselves not with elaborate hairstyles or gold or pearls or expensive clothes, but with good deeds, appropriate for women who profess to worship God.” Interestingly, today, I tend to avoid looking in the mirror, even as my powder room is covered in their winking surfaces. Mirrors and cameras create anxiety in me, and perhaps that is part of the reason I covered up the reflective surface in Vanitas. I wanted to thwart its use and deny the accusation of female vanity. Even the mirror I selected to flock was the least ornate of my collection. My relationship with mirrors is fraught, I cannot win the struggle of mind over matter, despite my values, endless self-help books, and attempts at radical self-love.

•

Marian Blue

Blue is the rarest colour in nature and a hue not produced by most living organisms. Many ancient languages lack a distinct word for blue, grouping it with green or even copper, with blue being consistently the last of the primary colours to be named. In fact, studies show that even today people from cultures that do not have a distinct word for blue have a much more difficult time differentiating blue from other colours. It is no wonder, then, that such an extraordinary colour, which must be named to be seen, alludes to the sacred. In Medieval and Renaissance Europe, blue pigment was made from the extremely rare lapis lazuli, found exclusively in Afghanistan. After its perilous and long journey along trade routes, it underwent lengthy processing of grinding and washing to be transformed into pigment, making its value greater in weight than gold. Its inordinate cost meant that it was used sparingly and was applied to the most prestigious subject matter in paintings. The supreme power of the Catholic church, especially as one of the only patrons of the arts in the Middle Ages, meant that blue was reserved for Mary, the mother of Jesus. It was an expression of devotion and glorification to Mary, who had taken on a special role in the Catholic church as the Queen of Heaven and intercessor. While she is not worshipped in Catholicism, she is venerated as a saint, and prayers are offered to her. Later, in the Renaissance, wealthy patrons commissioned paintings in which lapis lazuli blue pigment was used to indicate their own status. However, to this day this particular shade of blue continues to be known as “Marian Blue.”

In Catholicism Mary is given an exalted place above angels and saints and acts as a model of perfect love and obedience. The Reformation rejected all forms of idolatry, including veneration of saints, as blasphemous. The “Beeldenstorm,” meaning “statue storm,” of the 16th century saw outbreaks of destruction of religious images, especially in Germany and the Netherlands. During these spates of holy iconoclasm by Calvinist Protestants, Catholic art was destroyed by mobs. The destruction usually spilled over into monasteries and the homes of priests, in which statues and imagery of Mary were routinely destroyed. Exodus 20: 3 states, “…you shall not make for yourself a graven image…” and many Protestants took this to mean any religious imagery. Not only were the images of Mary destroyed, but so too, was her position in the church. The Protestant faith eliminated the positive, visible (if not also problematic) image of the female and feminine, replacing the ornate and decorative space of churches into austere, empty plainness. Therefore, the Catholic theological tradition that maintained the demand for lapis lazuli blue waned during the Reformation. The traditional church’s massive wealth to procure the pigment was lost and individual artists were less able to secure it for their secular commissions. Lapis lazuli, or ultramarine blue, became even more rare than it had been, trickling into Nuremberg in tiny pouches, ground into dust, waiting in oily stasis.

Jean-Baptiste Guimet, a chemist, invented a synthetic pigment to replicate Marian Blue in 1826. Guimet found work in the Administration des Poudres et Salpêtres in the production and management of gunpowder, used in France’s military and naval operations. In 1824 the Societé d’Encourgement pour l’Industrie Nationale offered a reward of six thousand francs to anyone who could develop a synthetic alternative to ultramarine. Guimet’s background in industrial chemical processes, particularly those involving high temperature kilns, favourably prepared him for the challenge. This helps to explain the odd chemical connection between gunpowder and synthetic ultramarine blue, as they share common ingredients.

Guimet’s bitter rival, Christian Gottlob Gmelin, also entered the competition and developed his own method for the synthesis of ultramarine. Technically, Gmelin was the first to arrive at a successful recipe and published his findings. However, Guimet kept his formula a closely guarded industrial secret and submitted to the Societé first, while Gmelin was less concerned with commercial interests. Because of Gmelin’s willingness to freely share his recipe, commercial production began shortly after he published his formula and it came to be known as the “Nuremberg process.” Both formulas continue to be manufactured to this day.

I grew up in the iconoclastic tradition of the Reformation, attending churches without sculptures, paintings, or stained glass. I did have access to images of artworks in musty books donated to the school I attended, which was conducted in that same church. If we were lucky enough to get one that had coloured plates, there I would see the Virgin Mary in her ultramarine robes. The rarity of that colour in art history and nature kept it reserved for the celestial, of course. This first wave of Marian Blue seldom sailed across the Atlantic, while the second wave of synthetic blue came in bulk. No longer in the province of the elite, it became a common household and industrial product. It was added to laundry detergent as an optical illusion called bluing, as well as wallpapers, textiles, ink, and cosmetics. No longer an elegant hue of the sacred or luxurious, it became an incredibly cheap and widely available pigment. Its associations with the domestic and its ubiquity, like the other objects explored in this text, somehow steal it of its status. I met Marian blue in its synthetic form, used in ink for Bible school illustrations of Mary, to make 70s blue eyeshadow, in Hollie Hobbie lunch kits, and household soap. It is the blue of the wallpaper from my childhood bedroom and makes me think of my family’s obsession with Delft Blue. Ultramarine blue is one of my least favourite paint colours, I prefer the inkiness of Prussian that leans towards black. When I ordered the ultramarine flocking, it was one of a limited palette, and once it arrived I felt that the colour could only function as symbolic. It isn’t the colour of nature, unless perhaps, the colour of my eyes, but still it is too vibrant to think of the sky or the ocean. Ultramarine can’t shake lapis lazuli, nor can it shake its Marian heritage; too blue, too pure, too heavenly to associate with anything but the esoteric.

•

Conclusion

Many are aware of Nuremberg, primarily as the location for the infamous International Military Tribunal to prosecute major Nazi leaders after WWII. What may be less well known is that Hitler selected Nuremberg as the logistic and symbolic heart of Nazism, due to its history, making it the critical site of restitution in the aftermath of the war. Prior, Nuremberg was considered by many to be the most German of German cities with many well-preserved structures from the Middle Ages to the Renaissance. It was also associated with German intelligence, ingenuity, and excellence. As an historic, powerful state, the Nazis exploited its history of political power to present the Third Reich as a logical continuation of Germany’s glorious past. Nuremberg was considered a place of “true believers,” receptive to Nazi racial ideologies, already set in motion with the Nuremberg Laws of 1935, which stripped Jewish people of their citizenship. However, it wasn’t only the symbolism that beckoned Hitler, it was also its terrain and location. Nuremberg sits at the center of Germany and had good rail connections for the hundreds of thousands of people to attend propaganda rallies. Nuremberg’s landscape was employed, once again, as a protective stronghold to guard, shelter, and secure.

WWII is the traumatic social rift that prompted my families to board ships from the Netherlands to North America. They endured the “Hongerwinter” (Hunger Winter), forced labour in concentration camps, and terror. Both sides of my family participated in hiding Jewish people escaping the Nazis, while my grandfathers hid under floorboards and in shacks while escaping the Gestapo. The Netherlands suffered immense devastation and social trauma, epigenetic legacies written into DNA sequences, the raw materials of new life, the bodies of children and grandchildren of survivors. These future generations are prone to many ill health conditions such as diabetes and heart disease, but also cortisol dysregulation, depression, anxiety, hypervigilance, eating disorders and PTSD.
SS Groote Beer
SS Volendam

This psychogeographic analysis of Nuremberg began with the premise that a river and a mountain offered protection and, thus, summoned all manner of matter to find their way across the Silk Road to the heart of Germany. From such a bastion grew power and wealth, where guilds, monasteries, and other patriarchal hierarchies of skill and knowledge thrived. This site of sovereignty was where flocking, mirrors, ultramarine blue, Christianity, and finally, the Third Reich found a place to morph, remediate, reform, or metastasize. Technologies of chemistry, of religion, of life, and of death were transformed in this place and made their way to the coast of the Atlantic to board ships. My epigenetic material left the Netherlands on the Groote Beer and the Volendam, in the DNA, the memories, the dreams, the faith, the fears, the flesh to be constituted in me, this current iteration of cosmic dust. Vibrant matter travelled across the planet and met once again via foot, cart, paintbrush, ship, and by stories to produce Vanitas.

About the author

Sharon VanStarkenburg is an artist-scholar, born in Pembroke, Ontario in 1974 to Dutch immigrant families. She earned a BFA from the University of Ottawa, studied at NYU at the graduate level, and earned an MFA from the University of Ottawa. She completed an MA in Contemporary Art Theory there, as well, and is currently a PhD candidate in the Cultural Mediations program at Carleton University. Her studio practice is a stream of research in the interdisciplinary program, as she focuses her research on research-creation, feminist autotheory, affect theory, vibrant matter, girlhood, and feminisms.

Her work is anchored in narrative and she explores themes of embodied realities such as performance of body and gender, grief, fear, joy and jouissance. With a feminist perspective informed by contemporary theories of identity, embodiment and subjectivity, she incorporate the personal and political; the emotional and intellectual; the individual and collective.

Countless Journeys, One Humanity.

Share This Story!

Stay In The loop

Stay connected with The Gallery of Human Migration by subscribing to our monthly e-newsletter!